When another driver is at fault, you generally recover for vehicle damage, rental, medical bills, and lost wages. You can file directly with their carrier (third-party claim), use your own coverage first (first-party, then subrogate), or in no-fault states use Personal Injury Protection (PIP) regardless of fault. Each path has trade-offs.
TipUse your collision coverage for fast repairs, then let your carrier subrogate. Your deductible is refunded out of the recovery and you get back on the road quickly.
⚠ Recorded statementsDo not give a recorded statement to the at-fault driver's carrier until you have spoken to your own carrier and, ideally, an attorney for injury cases.
Your three main paths
Choose based on speed, coverage, and the strength of the other driver's carrier.
- Third-party claim: file with the at-fault driver's liability insurer. Pros: no deductible, no premium impact. Cons: slower, the other carrier owes you nothing until liability is accepted.
- First-party claim with subrogation: file under your own collision coverage. Pros: fast, your carrier handles the fight. Cons: you pay the deductible up front (usually refunded after subrogation).
- PIP (no-fault states): use Personal Injury Protection for medical bills regardless of fault. Required in Florida, Michigan, New York, and 9 other no-fault states.
What you can recover
In an at-fault state, the at-fault driver's carrier owes you for actual losses. Recovery categories typically include:
- Vehicle damage (repair or ACV if totaled).
- Rental car while yours is in the shop (loss-of-use).
- Diminished value (the loss in market value caused by accident history).
- Medical bills and future medical care.
- Lost wages and reduced earning capacity.
- Pain and suffering (varies widely by state and severity).
No-fault states are different
12 states have some form of no-fault auto insurance, where your own PIP coverage pays for medical regardless of fault, and you can only sue the at-fault driver if injuries exceed a state threshold ("verbal" or "monetary" tort threshold).
- Pure no-fault: Florida, Hawaii, Kansas, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, Utah.
- Choice no-fault: Kentucky, New Jersey, Pennsylvania (you can opt out at policy purchase).
📚 Legal & Regulatory References
- State no-fault statutes (e.g., Fla. Stat. 627.730, Mich. Comp. Laws 500.3105, N.Y. Ins. Law 5102).
- NAIC consumer guide, "Auto Insurance: At-Fault vs No-Fault."
- State statutes of limitations for personal injury (typically 2-3 years from accident date).
- NAIC Unfair Claims Settlement Practices Model Act (MDL-900).
⚖ DisclaimerThis page is general consumer information, not legal or insurance advice. State laws and individual policy terms vary. For high-value disputes consult a licensed attorney or your state's department of insurance.
🔗 Related Guides
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Whose insurance pays first?
In at-fault states, the at-fault driver's liability carrier pays. In no-fault states, your own PIP pays first for medical regardless of fault, with limited rights to sue the other driver.
Will my rates go up if I was not at fault?
Usually no, but some carriers surcharge based on claim frequency regardless of fault. Check your state's laws (California, Oklahoma, and a few others prohibit not-at-fault surcharges).
Should I use my own collision or wait for the other carrier?
Use your own collision if you need the car fixed fast. Your carrier subrogates and you usually get your deductible back. Wait only if liability is undisputed and the other carrier has accepted promptly.
Can I get a rental car?
Yes. The at-fault carrier owes "loss of use," typically a rental of similar class for the entire repair period. If you use your own coverage you need rental reimbursement on your policy.
What is diminished value and can I claim it?
Diminished value is the loss in market value of your car simply because it has an accident history. About 30 states allow third-party diminished-value claims against the at-fault carrier. Your own carrier rarely owes it.
Do I need a lawyer?
Probably not for property damage only. For injury claims above a few thousand dollars, contingency-fee attorneys typically improve net recovery even after their cut.